Skip to content
Future Circle

A Proposal to Overhaul the Academy Programme and Assist Youth Players

Among the most cherished moments of this campaign came last week, viewing a promising talent charge up the pitch from his own box to seal a clinching strike.

Homegrown talents are invariably cherished by their team's fans and, based on my observations, the fanbase are going to experience many more exceptional displays from him in the time to follow.

Yet, for each success story, there are countless of other youngsters who fail to progress beyond the various phases, and must face a shattering disappointment at a tender age.

It is those individuals who fall away of youth football that are my focus, because I don't think the existing system does enough to educate them about their prospects, or look after them when they are discarded.

It requires an reform and, when I retired, I put together my own report into the academy system, with proposals for how it could be enhanced.

An Huge Investment – With Certain Significant Returns

The viewpoint on academies is more than as a ex- manager. My grandchildren are in the programme, so I've got a vested stake too.

For all aspiring footballers, the dream of becoming a pro player is a unique one. The academy system has been established to give them the best chance to achieve that ambition, with a formal initiative being introduced over a decade ago.

Currently, many thousands of boys are in the system, at clubs from the highest division down. It's an all-encompassing structure, with training no less than three nights a week and a games programme that consumes most of their weekends.

The equivalent framework is now being used by the rapidly expanding sport, girls football, too.

These academies are resourced at exceptional levels and create work for trainers, physios, medical staff and many more support staff.

The facilities are of the top level, with top-class indoor and outdoor fields. Schooling is included too, with lecturers hired to run compulsory academic programmes.

The outlay is enormous but, as we have witnessed, the clubs at the top end are gaining substantial returns on that investment through temporary transfers and sales of the academy-produced players.

The performance of the Present Plan?

The primary performance programme has been in operation for almost 15 years now, so how has it stood up to the passage of time?

Academies now run a pre-academy programme for kids from the age of six, so if any of them complete the full programme they would finish at 21. That's more time than a child spends in mainstream education, and lasts his complete childhood.

These kids are issued with club kit and coats, all badged up, and are seen by peers and relatives as being part of that club.

Their identity has, practically, been etched on them at a tender age and they also have to make a full dedication to the academy regime.

That means coaching on three evenings a week, and a games programme lasting most of the weekend, are now integral to a young player's quest to follow his ambition.

From my findings, in numerous cases what happens at school is seen as being secondary, with the academy becoming dominant and turning into the central focus of the child and his family's life.

A number of families see a pot of gold at the end of the journey if their child makes it and place tremendous pressure on their backs to break through.

Sadly, data show the system has a profound disparity of achievement and failure. We all see the ones who make it, but we seldom acknowledge those who don't succeed.

We Must Be Realistic About Their Odds

I don't want to take those dreams away from young players but we need to be honest with them about their chances.

While there are particular individuals a club will target as being potential professionals, the reality is a significant proportion of the players have only been on the pathway to fill the positions needed for coaching and the weekend matches at each age group.

I genuinely believe academies sufficiently communicate the expectations of these players or parents, about where they rank in the overall structure.

Players and parents must be given a comprehensive evaluation of where they stand, so they can plan for the probable disappointment when it occurs.

Our academies have developed some outstanding talent and there is more consideration paid to player welfare now than in the past, but let's also bring in a bit more focus on openness too.

More Emphasis on Schooling

As I stated above, I believe many youth players joining academies often take more notice of their coaches at times than they do of their schoolteachers.

It's vital this is recognised within the academy system, and youth managers relay this message to the coaches at each age group.

This dynamic itself is nothing new. Tutelage played a huge part in my youth, and PE teachers and coaches were always held in great esteem.

But, for those running an academy, they must make sure the coaches are given clear instructions and awareness of their responsibility because of the influence they have.

Levels of decorum, conduct and hard work should be as stringent as they are in any academic environment – and should extend to the educational side of the child's life there too.

The system I have put forward would have greater focus on studies and counselling – for families as well as the youth players – and also planning for what comes next if they are dropped aged 16.

The Plan to Help Youth Players

I would organise academies within a number of geographical areas, each run by a manager and partner them with accredited schools and colleges.

Prior to they get to apprenticeship level, players would be evaluated at 14 to see what academic track fits them.

At 16, players starting scholarships would begin in a compulsory combined academic programme with the academic partners.

Simultaneously, the players who are released at 16, can start a full-on combined academic programme with the schools or colleges.

The positive for them would be the establishment of a independent competitive programme where the schools and colleges would

Written by

Stephanie Kirk

Elara Vance is a tech journalist and futurist with over a decade of experience covering emerging technologies and their societal impacts.

Future Circle

Type to search articles.